The Case for Open Borders | My Assignment Tutor

As a Matter of Justice, Borders Should in Principle Be Open.Joseph H. Carens, in Aliens and Citizens: The Case for Open Borders, argues that as a matter of justice, borders should, in principle, be open’. ‘Borders’ in the context of this essay, are the boundaries of political-ge ties, which an individual cannot enter without the imprimatur of that state. For the purposes of this essay `justices is defined as social justice: that is the egalitarian, universal and non-discriminatory fundamental rights and opportunities all human beings believe they should have access to. As Herman Cohen argued, an asylum seeker should be “protected, not because he [is] a member of a family, clan, [or] religious community; but because he [is] a human being” (as quoted in Cole, 2003, n.p). Additionally, individual social justice, in John Stuart Mill’s proposition of consequentialiseds to be framed by the best possible social outcome for both the state and international:for example, a just solution to individuals seeking asylum in Australia must be the best possible solution for both Australians and asylum seekers. An asylum seeker, according to the Australian Human Rights Commission, is an individual who is“outside their own country and is unable or unwilling to return due to a -founded fear of being persecuted because of their race, religion, na ionality, membership to a particular social group, sexuality and or political opinion” (2014, n,p).Where this paper differs from Carens’ proposition as a matter ofjustice borders should in principle be open’ to all emigrants is in the


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *